|
Post by Xanadu on Aug 31, 2003 1:22:34 GMT
I was wondering what each of us finds the most compelling aspect of Kate Bush. For further explanation: Musical Talent: the actual musical compositions and arrangements move you the most. Lyrical Abilities: you find yourself constantly surprised at the lyrics and poetry of her songs. Vocal Delivery: her unusual vocal range and more unusual use of it! Subject Choices: has the ablitiy to write songs about the most incredible subject matter. Feminity and Appearance: her beauty, grace, poise, and sexuality. Theatrical Performace: you are entranced with the live footage of incredible performances, mime and such. Dance Presentations: her ability to be not only a great musician, but mostly a wonderful interpretive dancer. Other: anything I didn't think of! So, after you vote, be sure to explain why. I think this ties in with Kate's influences and how we are touched by her art. And maybe some theories on Moments of Pleasure. ;D
|
|
|
Post by Al Truest on Aug 31, 2003 2:49:56 GMT
I love Kate for ALL the qualities you've listed; but, the most compelling aspect would be, for me, her theatrical ability. The combination of the way she moves, looks (especially her eyes) and sounds create a charisma that is hyptonitic. She is the most visually provocative performer that I know of. Her voice, lyrics and appearance are all a part of the package. Even when you don't see her perform, you are captivated by the way she gets 'into character'. The cadence, phrasing and vocal gymnastics are all weapons in her arsenal. All of her talents co-exist in the theatre she creates. Once you're hooked, the subject matter and the poetry just embellish what she has already delivered- Art.
|
|
|
Post by Lori on Aug 31, 2003 21:33:35 GMT
Can't vote cos it's all of these:
Lyrical Abilities Theatrical Performances Dance Presentations
|
|
|
Post by Xanadu on Sept 2, 2003 22:42:22 GMT
I know, it's nearly impossible to choose. But really, if you have too, just for discussion's sake.
Al' you didn't vote.
What's created is the entire package, and I believe that as well, but what one aspect is the most critical for you? What you think puts her above other music we're interested? What in your opinion is the key element of her longevity and originality?
It is the combination of all these, but for each of us, I think there is the first element that grabbed our attention, with the other's quickly following.
It's sort of like being in love... it is an infinite number of aspects of the other's personality and appearance that attracts you. But what one thing could you never be without...?
|
|
|
Post by Al Truest on Sept 3, 2003 0:10:47 GMT
Sorry, I forgot to cast my vote. (just did through) However, I did answer correctly. She just uses more of her tools in her "Theatrical Performances" Her work is about telling stories creatively. It is good theatre whether we see her or not. I know that sounds like a cheesy answer; but, that's her hook. It doesn't matter what the words are or the story is, if you are not compelled to take initial notice, then the mark has been missed. Her perfornance is what got me from her first time I saw her. I believe she is a 'performance artist 'more than she is singer, dancer or songwriter.
|
|
|
Post by Xanadu on Sept 3, 2003 0:40:45 GMT
That's what I was looking for! Knew you'd come through! ;D ;D I don't know if there's a right or wrong answer here, just what we feel are the strongest aspects. Personally, I think for Kate, it has been an evolving process. Initially dance may have been the medium of her choice to express herself, but later it becomes video. She even explains this change after the RUTH video was made, as a send off for the interpretive dancer and the beginning of film visuals. Maybe each incarnation has it's own strength?
|
|
|
Post by Al Truest on Sept 3, 2003 1:19:14 GMT
Personally, I think for Kate, it has been an evolving process. Initially dance may have been the medium of her choice to express herself, but later it becomes video. She even explains this change after the RUTH video was made, as a send off for the interpretive dancer and the beginning of film visuals. Maybe each incarnation has it's own strength? I agree with your observations. But, ultimately it's about the performance to Kate (I think) As she evolves she will utilize her wisdom over her youthful exurberence. Her commitment to excellence remains constant though. It helps explain the long wait between projects. I believe she will only be ready to release her new album when everyone's perfomance, including her own, meets the standard of her vision.
|
|
|
Post by strabley on Sept 3, 2003 7:42:32 GMT
I think I should have voted for lyrical abilities, but I voted for subject choices because she always keeps me fascinated yet I relate to the letting the weirdness in. I'm not sure I understand the difference between the 2 selections...I also am in awe of the way she can twist and beautify the words she wants to say...
|
|
|
Post by birgittesc on Sept 29, 2003 7:37:13 GMT
My vote went to the vocal thingie option (sorry, short memory today LOL), oh wait it was 'vocal delivery' right? Whatever. Anyway, what first attracted me to her music was her extraordinary vocal style, which is mostly notable in her first three albums. Needless to say I'm not highly enthousiastic about what followed after that... Birgitte
|
|
|
Post by Al Truest on Oct 6, 2003 23:00:39 GMT
I'd like to hear what some of the new members think about this thread.
|
|
|
Post by Xanadu on Nov 21, 2003 19:42:15 GMT
I agree Al, I'd like to hear what some of you think.
I finally placed my vote as Subject Matter, with a close second to Vocal Delivery - followed by Lyrical Ability. My choice is because I hadn't even seen her in live (aside from the Gabriel video for Don't Give Up) until I was a huge fan. Not even a video. So the theatrical performance and dance aspects did not entrace me until much later.
I do think she is incredibly talented musically, of course, but many artists are. I think there is something more rare in the combination of the beautiful melodies with the unusual subject choices and lyrics that keeps my interest.
And, the performance factor has certainly wained in the later years, with no real mime, dance or live shows.
So, what's is Kate's appeal for you...?
|
|
|
Post by Al Truest on Dec 13, 2003 17:27:15 GMT
If you haven't voted here, please do so.
|
|
|
Post by Xanadu on Jan 14, 2004 19:12:25 GMT
;Ddigging again ;D I'd like to see what emerges here as what we regard as the most appealing aspect of Kate's career. I know more of you have an opinion, please share it.
|
|
|
Post by ~ Rocket's Tail ~ on Jan 14, 2004 19:48:02 GMT
I'm a musician, so I've gone with "Musical Talent." Every aspect of Kate enthralls me, but her chord sequences never fail to amaze... and her song structures are so unique. RUTH... one of the most effective songs I've heard that doesn't need to change key! Damnit, "I Wanna Be Kate"
|
|
|
Post by Xanadu on Feb 26, 2004 23:59:37 GMT
I'd like to see some comments from the new folks... you know who you are...
|
|